The moment you came home the other night   I could tell that something wasn't right   I ask you what the silence is about   Then all I did was listen while you poured your heart out      And then your eyes looked into mine   And we saw forever was right there all the time   When I held you in my arms it said all there was to say   It should've happened that way, it should've happened that way      Woke up again this morning way too soon   Wish I was fast asleep and still with you   I'd give anything if I could feel how I did when I was dreaming   I could've sworn that it was real      And when your eyes looked into mine   And we saw forever was right there all the time   When I held you in my arms it said all there was to say   It should've happened that way, it should've happened that way      If we could have this chance again   I only wish that we could be what we might have been      I should've never let you leave   I could've made you stay   It should've happened that way, yeah, yeah   It should've happened that way