Looking through the moonlight baby,    and what do I see    Reflections of the times we had,   and how it used to be    Two lovers that were looked as   one as one looked to be loved    A romance that would take its cause ,and guided from above    and caring like a fool , gave it all to you    Expecting in return a love so new and true    You cheated and lied your way right from the start    So don't expect the place to be right in my heart       Chorus:    Thief of hearts, you said you'd never let me go    You broke my heart, you promised me you'd never leave me from the start    And all the dreams I had for you went much too far    Your a thief of hearts       Remembering the moments we had,    how could they slip away    You promised me a love so true,   it had to end this way    I can't imagine you'd be so cruel    to play me like a game    It seems the love I thought we had    could never be the same    But oh, oh how I loved you so    With words I tried to let you know    Now its time for me to make a brand new start    The scars left behind are hurting in my heart       why ooo why    tell me why    your a thief of my heart      Chorus (4x)