I gave you my heart in the hopes that you might give me yours   But now I'm at the point of losing you   Your laugh and your smile made me feel everything was secure   And that no one could love me like you do      You should have told me it wasn't forever   Your eyes tell me things that your heart cannot say   You should have told me that you were not ready to love   You should have told me that you could not stay with me      Oh I love you      I gave you my trust, thinking no one could love me so much   And I hate to think that it could never end   The warmth of your touch cast upon me a feeling I know   Two people share when they are more then friends      You should have told me it wasn't forever   Your eyes tell me things that your heart cannot say   You should have told me that you were not ready to love   You should have told me that you could not stay with me      Is it my loving you that makes you be this way?   I feel like such a fool, you've brought me so much pain   You should have told me something, not lead me to believe   That we'd be together forever and ever      You should have told me it wasn't forever   Your eyes tell me things that your heart cannot say   You should have told me that you were not ready to love   You should have told me that you could not stay with me      You should have told me it wasn't forever   Your eyes tell me things that your heart cannot say   You should have told me that you were not ready to love   You should have told me that you could not stay with me      You should have told me, tell me, tell me   You should have told me