Proceeding with Catherine is a dangerous road to walk   'Cause she's cold and still and she paints her will   Alone in her bedroom hands covered in chalk   You know she must inhale the dust to talk   I never meant to hurt you   I only wanted someone to be a friend   And though you still seem willing   I know better than to trust you again   Fooling me twice would be a sin   Proceeding with caution is a difficult way to be loved   I know it's safe, my kind of place   What's the worst that could happen?   Could slip and fall back into the night   She's sinking in our hearts again   Trust   I never meant to hurt you   I only wanted someone to be a friend   And though you still seem willing   I know better than to trust you again   Fooling me twice would be a sin