I lay shaking in the night   Wondering if you were alright   What do you know is true   Is it what I already knew   I already knew      All the stars up in the sky   Still don't understand why you cry   Why do you cry?   As I gaze up at the moon   I wonder if we moved too soon   Or has it all just been a lie   I hope that this isn't goodbye   It's not goodbye      All these questions need answers   And I need you   But I don't know what you already knew   You already knew      All these questions still need answers   Thoughts of you still haunt me   Like a painless cancer   I thought I had the choice to make   But my choice had already been made   And you knew who I'd choose   And you knew what I'd do   And you knew, and you knew   You already knew