As many have read in the book and many are about to see in the movie, there is another controversy regarding the Bible and its many claims about Jesus. I am not about to defend or attack either side of this controversy. My aim is to put the claims of the Da Vinci Code proponents under the purely logical analysis of the philosophical approach that is called Aristotelian logic.
You may not be aware of it but you are using this approach to your decision making every day. According to this system of thought, if our conclusions are going to be sound we must follow strict rules reaching these conclusions after looking at the data involving a certain issue. In its simplest form here is what Aristotelian logic is all about.
You start with one or two obvious and universally accepted premises. These are called axioms. Then you use the three simple rules of logic. First is: A=A, an object or a statement is equal to itself. Second: If A=B then B=A. Third: If A=B and B=C then A=C. When you start with an axiom or two and you apply these three rules consistently and correctly then your conclusions will be sound. So in order to analyze any argument you need to first find out what the underlying assumptions or axioms are. Then you proceed to apply the three rules and determine if they have been correctly applied in arriving at the conclusions of the one or the other side of the controversy. Let’s look at an example. Let’s start with the two axioms that people not too long ago accepted unquestionably and universally. One is “The Earth Is Flat", the second is “All Material Things Come To An End" third “Flat things have edges". Suppose you want to decide whether to travel all your life in the same direction. What would be the soundest decision according to Aristotelian Logic? Applying the three rules of logic we will have to say. The earth is a material thing therefore the earth has an end. Flat things have edges therefore the earth has edges. So based on your data that the earth is flat and the earth is a material thing your best decision would be to forget about traveling in the same direction for too long you might fall of the edge and who knows where you are going to end up. Notice that the erroneous conclusion is not due to the thought process, it is a result of a faulty axiom.
Now let us try to apply this logic to the Da Vinci code controversy. What are the underlying axioms in this whole issue? Historical data about the life of Jesus are at best inconclusive so even the biggest skeptic will have to agree that in this whole argument the axiom is “The Bible Is Authoritative and Reliable". Thinking in Aristotelian logic terms this is the big problem. The vast majority of the people who care about the Bible, believe that the Bible consists of the 39 books of the Old Testament and the 27 books of the New Testament. Remember that in order for the statement “The Bible Is Reliable" to be an axiom there must be universal agreement. How can we consider it then an axiom if people do not even agree what the Bible is? It appears to me that the proponents of the Da Vinci code argument are attempting to appropriate the standing of the Bible as an authoritative source by arguing that the gospel of Thomas and other such writings belong to and are a part of “The Bible". The irony of this approach is that this attempt to include more books in the Bible in order to appropriate its authority is the very same thing that strips the authority of the Bible because there is no longer universal agreement on what the Bible is so how can there be universal validity to the axiom “The Bible Is An Authoritative Source Of Information"? Of course the objection will be raised, the flat earth axiom was universally accepted and it was wrong! The problem here is that Galileo had compelling observational data to overturn a universal misconception. What do the Da Vinci code proponents have that is compelling enough to change the number of the books of the Bible. Lets look at the book of Thomas, which they claim belongs in the Bible and supports their claims. Here is a quote from it “ He saw a Samaritan carrying a lamb and going to Judea. He said to his disciples, “that person … around the lamb." They said to him, “So that he may kill it and eat it." He said to them, “He will not eat it while it is alive, but only after he has killed it and it has become a carcass." They said, “Otherwise he can’t do it." He said to them, “So also with you, seek for yourselves a place for rest, or you might become a carcass and be eaten."
Is this the source of the compelling evidence? If I had to support any of my arguments on a book with such childish writing I would be ashamed to show my face in public!
In conclusion, the Da Vinci code may be a nice novel but it is just noise when it comes to establishing its claims as true history.
Da Vinci Code Controversy
What good is such practice? Some might ask in our busy yang energy go-get-em world. Creativity and inspiration come from the unseen, the yin, the receptive, the intuitive. Albert Einstein once said, "Imagination is more important that knowledge." Einstein didn't devalue the masculine or yang consciousness, for he also defined success as "10% inspiration and 90% perspiration." However, he did exalt the yin, feminine, intuitive consciousness as the MOST important. For without that all important "spark" of awareness or inspiration which can only come from quiet contemplative thought, the 90% perspiration would be as purposeful as a "busy" hamster running around its endless wheel that leads nowhere. Just as many of the world's actions today are resulting in environmental and political messes that could easily be avoided, if preceded by deep "contemplation" before action occurs. Too often our endless business (busy-ness) is not purposeful at all as far as solving our global problems, but to the unaware observer the decision makers look "very important" and "very busy."
Mind/body sciences like yoga, and tai chi, and qigong (energy exercise), are designed to allow the flow of life energy to permeate the mind and body, and to create a "receptive/open state of mind in the practitioner," a passive alpha state of awareness. Qi, life energy in Traditional Chinese Medical science, is a subtle unseen power that emerges from the very fabric of the subatomic field that makes up all matter, and permeates all things including human beings. Acupuncture, and Chinese herbal medicine, as well as physical exercises like Tai Chi & Qigong are designed to open the flow of life energy through the mind and body. Yoga and Ayurvedic practices are designed to do this as well.
In this field of life energy all things are connected, and therefore insights from this pure consciousness can be powerfully complex solutions that seem simple and elegant and obvious, once they come to mind. Yet offer more comprehensive communally beneficial solutions to challenges facing the practitioner cultivating this "field" awareness in themselves through these ancient practices. Tai Chi may help cultivate such intuitive, receptive states of mind if taught to that end. Tai Chi, incorporated with gentle deep breathing, and physical loosening, and mental images of constantly "letting go" of everything enables this unseen force of the universe to flow through us, emanating from every cell and atom of our being, and expanding effortlessly from each airy fold of the tissues of our mind. We can allow every atom of our being to glow with and be permeated by this energy of life as we move through the flowing motions of Tai Chi "without purpose," "without analysis," "without grades, or self judgments." But rather, only for the sheer pleasure of being, while experiencing the thousands of wonderful sensations tingling and percolating through the body. Tai Chi becomes an effortless "self massage" that flows through the yielding heart, mind, and body. This state is not "directed" by the mind, but allows the mind to let go and be massaged by the pleasant sensations flowing through it, holding on to nothing, not analyzing or even naming the sensations caressing, washing the mind as they flow through receptive awareness.
Today's current knee jerk reactions which get us individually into such trouble on crowded freeways, or in global trouble as a nation in an increasingly crowded world, have been cultivated over centuries of under-developing our feminine or yin consciousness. Our television pundits automatically react and narrow dialogue without even being conscious of it. In a three month period leading up to the Iraq war, Fair Media did a study of major news networks coverage of the impending conflict. They found a disturbing reality, that over 90% of the talking head guests on their news shows were already assuming there was a war to be fought, and discussing war strategy. Only less than 5% of the talking heads were opposed to, or even skeptical, about the idea of going to war. This hard charging into action, rather than "contemplating", is an example of the result of centuries of male energy being accepted and extolled, and yin or feminine energy being dismissed and considered "indecisive" and "weak minded."
The pool of "receptive" sensation that Tai Chi or other ancient transcendental technologies can bathe us in again and again, day after day, enables the subtle possibilities and gentle power of the yin and feminine to permeate our being and consciousness, and through that, affect our actions in the world. It can change the way we function, so that rather than charging into personal, or social, or national decisions, we instinctively "contemplate" and "intuit" all the possible outcomes of that action "BEFORE" taking that action. This could keep us out of costly wars, and reduce futile quests to find where on earth to dump thousands of tons of highly toxic nuclear waste that will be poisonous for tens of thousands of years. It may open us up to more subtle "yielding" approaches to international relations, that can get us the desired results through the subtle dance of negotiation which entails "listening" before "acting," which is a very yin or feminine quality. It may draw us more to "passive" energy solutions like "solar" or "wind" that could easily solve all our energy needs, and we would never need to fight anyone anywhere over the sun or the wind, which is available to all equally.
Transcendental mind/body technologies like Tai Chi, Yoga, transcendental meditation, Chi Kung, etc. can today be made available to billions of people worldwide at a time when the world desperately needs to learn to find a balance in the deepest part of our being, a balance that extols the subtle and quiet power of the feminine or yin aspect of who we are individually and as communities and nations. Tai Chi and Yoga, for example, are now taught in virtually every nation in the world, and can perhaps now contribute to solving humanity's hunger for balance between the "male" and "female," between the "yin" and the "yang."
Generations may look back and see that Tai Chi & Yoga teachers of today played a pivotal role in human history. Or perhaps the changes they are making in the world are so subtle and gentle, that they will never be recognized but nevertheless . . . will ease the world into its next wave of evolution enabling it to survive the weight of six billion plus inhabitants, without creating chaos through rash actions.
Both John Douramacos Douramacos & Bill Douglas are contributors for EditorialToday. The above articles have been edited for relevancy and timeliness. All write-ups, reviews, tips and guides published by EditorialToday.com and its partners or affiliates are for informational purposes only. They should not be used for any legal or any other type of advice. We do not endorse any author, contributor, writer or article posted by our team.
John Douramacos Douramacos has sinced written about articles on various topics from SEO linking. John Douramacos is a marketer. with interest in forex trading. John Douramacos Douramacos's top article generates over 880 views. to your Favourites.
Bill Douglas has sinced written about articles on various topics from Build Muscle, Fitness and Mortgage Insurance. Bill Douglas is the founder of World Tai Chi & Qigong Day, and author of the best selling tai chi book, "The Complete Idiot's Guide to T'ai Chi & Qigong" (Penguin Putnam), and presenter in the world acclaimed DVD instructional "Anthology of T'ai Chi & Qig. Bill Douglas's top article generates over 4400 views. to your Favourites.
Add My Site To Search Engines Since a search engine is a tool, not something you can spam. Smart clients are Wising up Some clients ask alleged White Hat SEOs