When considering the greatest hitters in baseball history there are a few criteria that must be taken into consideration. The first criteria is peak performance. The second criteria is career performance. How long was a hitter great? And the third criteria is era.When taking into account each of these criteria I've come up with the following list of the three greatest hitters in the history of major league baseball.
It is important to note when reading this that I am not considering defensive skill when compiling this list. It's entirely about hitting. I'm also not going to give a player more credit as a hitter because they are a shortstop instead of a left fielder. I realize that when considering "replacement value" a great hitting shortstop can be more valuable than an even greater hitting left fielder but that's beyond the scope of this article.
#1 Barry Bonds - Certainly this will be a controversial pick, but it's also the obvious choice. Barry Bonds is, in fact, the greatest hitter who has ever played the game of baseball. His major competition is Ted Williams and Babe Ruth who I believe should both be somewhat marked down due to inferior competition, but even without such a mark down, Barry Bonds dominates when talking about best peak performance.
Based on OPS+, Bonds had the three greatest seasons in baseball history (2002, 2004, & 2001 - in that order.) Babe Ruth had the next best 3 seasons and Ted Williams the next best 2 seasons. Incredibly it's then Bonds at #9 (2003) and Ruth again at #10 and #11. What's that mean? The top 11 greatest hitting seasons of all time were all by these three hitters. There's no surprise then that these are the top three hitters of all time on my list.
Bonds has to be #1 though, because his peak was higher than any other peak and he did it in a much more competitive era than did Ruth or Williams.
Of course Bonds also has some great career numbers (most obviously as the all time leader in home runs, but he's also the career leader in walks & runs created) but it's his peak performance numbers that make him the greatest hitter of all time. He holds the single season record for slugging percentage, on base percentage, OPS, OPS+, walks, & home runs.
It's also worth noting that of these three great hitters, Bonds is the only one who was a great base runner (over 500 career stolen bases) and while I did make note that I am not considering defense when compiling this list, I do think it's worth pointing out as a curiosity that Bonds is also the only one of the three who was a great defensive player (not counting Babe Ruth's amazing pitching skill of course.)
#2 Babe Ruth - If you look at overall career rate stats then Babe Ruth cannot be topped. Ruth is the career leader in slugging percentage & OPS. He's second in career on base percentage. But I do think it's not fair to give Ruth the #1 slot only because of these career rate stats. Ruth's career rate stats were not pulled down by early poor seasons like Bonds' were. Also, as mentioned earlier, the competition during this era was just not nearly as strong.
Still, you can make a strong argument that Ruth should be #1. To get an idea of how dominant Ruth was, he lead the AL in OPS 13 of 14 seasons from 1918 to 1931. The only year he didn't lead was his injury shortened season of 1925. Bonds streak as a truly dominant hitter was shorter but even more impressive.
#3 Ted Williams - Williams .406 season in 1941 is still the last season anyone has hit over .400, over 60 years later. Williams is the all time leader in career on base percentage (.482) Ted Williams is second all time in career slugging percentage (after only Ruth.) There are many career rate stats where Williams is only behind Ruth and many single season rate stats where Williams is only behind Bonds. But the fact is, in both instances, he is behind Ruth & Bonds and while I can still see a good argument for Williams to be #1, it seems in the end he loses out to Barry Bonds & Babe Ruth. He's my choice for the 3rd greatest hitter in major league history.
Honorable Mentions: Ty Cobb, Rogers Hornsby, Lou Gehrig, Mickey Mantle, Jimmie Fox, & the best hitter currently playing: Albert Pujols.
The History Of Baseball
The first and earliest written evidence of baseball in America is a bylaw written
in 1791 in Pittsfield, Massachusetts. The document, discovered by Society for
Baseball Research member John Thorn in 2004, offers strong evidence that
baseball is a unique American game, and it casts doubt on the long held
belief that baseball was derived from rounders, a British game. It also raises
the question of the origins of cricket, as it has been widely thought that
baseball followed cricket, which was developed from a folk game known as
stool ball (1085 A.D).
As far back as 2000 B.C. ball and stick type games have been played.
Hieroglyphics depict ancient Egyptians playing a game similar to baseball in
1500 B.C., although there exists some major differences between its depiction
and the modern game.
The 1791 Massachusetts by-law banned the playing of the game within 80
yards of the town meeting house. The first documented formal organization to
play baseball in America was the NY Knickerbockers established on
September 23, 1845. The first rules were written by Alexander Cartwright,
considered to be the Father of modern baseball. However, long before this
time ball playing of one sort or another was noted by many authors and in
many documents.
A May 8, 1844 city Ordinance in New York City prohibits "ball" playing of any
sort. Abner Doubleday was said to have "invented" the game of baseball in
1839, although a later inquiry proved this to be a myth. Cartwright??s role in
baseball has also been questioned. Most experts and historians now agree
that he was simply the first to write down the rules that had existed for quite
some time. In addition, there is strong evidence that rule changes were one of
the reasons Cartwright wrote them down.
There has been a lot written about the sport after the founding of the
Knickerbockers, such as articles about the popularity and evolvement of the
"New York Game" rules into the mainstream of baseball. The original
Knickerbocker rules addressed foul lines and deleted the "plug out," which
involved hitting the runner with the ball to gain an out. They also delineated
the tag-out and the force-out. Strangely, they don??t provide a pitching distance
or a baseline length. Forty-two paces was the actual written distance from
home to second base, and from first to third. "Innings" were also not
mentioned. Instead, the first team to twenty-one was declared the winner,
given both teams are allowed an equal number of at-bats. The pitching
method was also described as underhand, perhaps similar to town ball,
another early game with English roots.
The rules may have first been written by Cartwright, but there is a long and
involved history of earlier games with similar rules. Many American and
opposing English claims of inventing baseball have tried to argue their
positions by presenting evidence to back their claims. Despite all of this, the
origin of modern baseball still remains a mystery.
After 1845, the history of baseball in America starts to be fairly clear. The rules
were standardized in 1857. In 1858, the first baseball league, the National
Association of Base Ball Players (NABBP), emerged. They were not
considered professional players, as they received no money for their
participation. However, the games were public and admission was charged to
witness the games. The first documented college baseball game was played
in 1859 as Amherst defeated Williams 73-32 in 26 innings in Pittsfield,
Massachusetts.
In 1860, the "New York Game" was commonly referred to as "the National
pastime" in many written works. Baseball gained momentum in popularity and
slowly spread throughout the Country during the Civil War. Over 100 clubs
were in existence when the war ended and in 1869, the world's first
professional baseball team was established. The Cincinnati Red Stockings
ended their first season undefeated. The NABBP split into two groups, one for
the amateurs and one for the professionals. The amateur leg of the
association dissolved after only a few years.
The National League, which still exists, was established in 1875 after the
NABBP proved ineffective on several levels. The power shifted to the club
organizations and baseball entered into an age full of conflict, remembered
mostly for the dreaded player reserve clause that oppressed players and held
them as "slaves" to their contracts.
Blacks and Hispanics or any other non-white players were repeatedly forced
out, left out, or sent to the minor leagues. This was a shameful practice that
didn??t end until 1947. The Western League of Baseball Players, a minor
league of the Great Lakes States area became the American League in 1899.
A new era in baseball began in 1901. It was known as the "Dead Ball Era",
because of a sharp decrease in offense produced in both leagues. This era
continued until the emergence of Babe Ruth in 1919.
Both Marvin J Markus & Fr Penn are contributors for EditorialToday. The above articles have been edited for relevancy and timeliness. All write-ups, reviews, tips and guides published by EditorialToday.com and its partners or affiliates are for informational purposes only. They should not be used for any legal or any other type of advice. We do not endorse any author, contributor, writer or article posted by our team.
Marvin J Markus has sinced written about articles on various topics from Fitness, Facts about Barack Obama and Family. Marvin J. Markus is a contributor to the big show baseball blog which includes a store with . Marvin J Markus's top article generates over 550000 views. to your Favourites.
Fr Penn has sinced written about articles on various topics from Recreation and Sports, Cars and Recreation and Sports. This article was written by FR Penn sponsored by http://www.stubhub.com. If you're looking for baseball tickets to see your favorite team live in action, look no further than Stubhub.com where fans buy and sell the hottest baseball tickets. Reproductions. Fr Penn's top article generates over 1000000 views. to your Favourites.
Clubbers Guide Spring 2008 Aphrodite just met her competition ladies. Be confident, be beautiful, be you. Whatever you decide to wear this season, just remember to own it.