There's moonlight on the trees   Paintin' silver on the leaves   It's so beautiful out here, I just had to stop and stare   That's unusual for me      I had a happy heart of stone   No voice to answer but my own   Now I want more from the night since you waltzed into my life   You couldn't leave well enough alone      Why out of all the people in this world   Why did you set your sights and single out this girl?   Oh, why did you have to go and make me love you?      Why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?      In an instant sweet and strange   Everything about me changed   Whether I want to or not, I come to you with all I've got   And I'll never be the same      Why out of all the people in this world   Why did you set your sights and single out this girl?   Oh, why did you have to go and make me love you?      Why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?   Tell me why, why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?      Maybe this is just a dream   Or maybe this was meant to be   I just pinch myself and wonder why      Why out of all the people in this world   Why did you set your sights and single out this girl?   Oh, why did you have to go and make me love you?      Why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?   Tell me why, why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?      Why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?   Tell me why, why'd you have to go and make me   Why'd you have to go and make me love you?